A lan Milburn spoke powerfully on the prime minister’s behalf today. Nick Robinson, of the BBC, pointed out that his report on young people and work tells nine cabinet ministers what to do, and asked: “Have you looked Andy Burnham in the eye and said: ‘Are you going to do this?’” Milburn said he had, and that he believed Burnham would do it. “It is something that is seared on his soul.” Milburn has done a remarkable job of preaching about the “moral crisis” of youth unemployment , and he and Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, have mounted an exceptional sales pitch to the Labour Party for a solution that does actually mean, as Milburn admitted today, that “some people will be worse off – initially”.
Now that Milburn’s report has been published, however, we can see that the plan is still rather cloudy, and that neither McFadden nor Burnham have yet committed themselves to anything. All in all, it is a brilliant example of Burnham’s strategy of talking left but acting pragmatically. The numbers are unclear.
Milburn was guilty of overselling the savings in his interviews today. He told Robinson that “savings can start this parliament”, which is just about true, as his report says that they won’t materialise until the financial year starting in April 2029, and the latest possible date for a general election is August 2029. More importantly, though, the report says that any savings will be outweighed by the costs of the plan until 2036.
The “upfront cost”, Milburn said today, is a cool half-billion next year – if the government “gets a lick on” and legislates for the changes in the first parliamentary session of next year. Except that in a fiscal device known as “making up the numbers”, the cost will not be additional public spending, but a “reprioritisation” of other budgets – or even, in the words of Milburn’s report, a “radical reprioritisation”. The cost then rises to £5.8bn a year over 10 years – during which time, Milburn explains in his report, there are expected to be “three spending reviews” – and it is only then, in 2036, that he estimates that the savings will be greater than the costs.
So instead of Starmer and Reeves’s attempt to save £5bn a year by the end of this parliament, which was blocked by a rebellion of Labour MPs last year, Milburn is hoping to break even by the end of the next parliament. He will argue that this is the way to achieve fundamental reform, which will produce net savings after that. Whether that is good enough is another question.
It all depends on the truth of Milburn’s assertion that “crude cuts” simply end up costing the taxpayer more elsewhere and over the longer term. You can understand the scepticism expressed by even moderate Conservatives. David Cameron , in another of his rare interventions, exclaimed this morning: “When you look at the size of this working-age welfare bill that has gone up by so much, is it really the case that we can’t make some savings more quickly?” Former health secretary Alan Milburn has unveiled a plan to reduce the number of young people on benefits (Getty) (Getty) But maybe this is the only way to get even the smallest change past the Parliamentary Labour Party.
Say the government will spend more in the short term on a moral crusade to rescue young people from a lifetime on benefits, while fudging the figures. Talk about the biggest “employment support package” ever, while slipping in references to the plan not being “pain-free”. Get some sketchy legislation through parliament and then tighten up the rules in practice.
McFadden did a good job selling the plan as a moral mission rather than a Treasury-driven cost-cutting exercise in his TV interviews on Sunday. When Laura Kuenssberg challenged him to say that the working-age welfare bill would be lower by the time of the next election, McFadden said: “Let me tell you where this goes wrong. When people pick a number and retro-fit a policy to it.
We’ve had some recent experience of this and that’s why this is something very different.” By “recent experience”, he meant the Starmer-Reeves attempt to cut £5bn a year. This, he said, is “a different idea, it’s a much more fundamental and long term idea; this is not the same thing as we tried last year with different PR. This is a different policy, a different approach and that’s why I think it’s going to lead to a better outcome for the million young people not in education, employment or training.” But if the best that he and Milburn – the most powerful person in British politics today – can do is to start to reduce the rate of increase in net welfare spending on young people in 10 years’ time, what is the point?
Source: The Independent
World Post



